NTSB Factual Report

HISTORY OF FLIGHT

On March 1, 2014, about 1215 eastern standard time, a Beech F33A, N7203E, was destroyed when it collided with trees and terrain near Lumberport, West Virginia. The private pilot was fatally injured. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and no flight plan was filed for the local personal flight, which departed Fairmont Municipal Airport (4G7), Fairmont, West Virginia, and was conducted under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91.

A witness, who was standing in a valley just beyond a small mountain where the accident occurred, stated that he did not see the airplane prior to the accident, but heard an engine sputtering, then go to full power. He subsequently heard trees and branches breaking, and metallic sounds, then looked up to see trees and branches falling and airplane debris descending down the side of the mountain. The witness then proceeded up the side of the mountain where he saw the remnants of the airplane.

Radar information revealed that the airplane departed 4G7, elevation 1,032 feet msl, about 1140. It subsequently headed west-southwest, initially climbing to cruising altitudes of 3,500 to 3,600 feet msl by 1143, but after 1148, continued outbound at 3,300 to 3,400 feet.

At 1203, and nearing the Ohio border, the airplane turned right and reversed course, tracking eastbound, back toward 4G7 and almost directly over the outbound course. It generally maintained altitudes between 3,300 feet and 3,400 feet until 1210, when it climbed to 3,500 feet. By 1211:40, the airplane had climbed to 4,000 feet, and by 1212:51, it had descended to 3,100 feet. The airplane then climbed again, to 3,500 feet by 1213:52, but then descended and maintained between 3,400 feet and 3,200 feet until 1214:49, when it had climbed again to 3,600 feet. It subsequently began a final descent; at 1215:08, the airplane was at 2,800 feet, at 1215:12, it was at 2,600 feet, and at 1215:17, at last radar contact, the airplane was at 1,800 feet. There were no major course deviations noted during the airplane's descent.

PERSONNEL INFORMATION

The pilot, age 68, held a private pilot certificate with airplane single engine land and instrument-airplane ratings. His latest FAA third class medical certificate was issued on November 1, 2012. At the time, the pilot indicated 1,550 total hours of flight time, with 30 hours in the previous 6 months. No logbook was located at the accident site, and the logbooks provided to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) by the pilot's family only listed flights through 1997.

AIRPLANE INFORMATION

The single engine metal airplane was powered by a Continental IO-520-series engine driving a three-bladed metal propeller. The latest annual inspection was completed on January 4, 2014. At the time, the airplane had operated 1,995.7 hours, and the engine 897.0 hours since new.

METEROROLOGICAL INFORMATION

The weather, recorded at an airport 9 nm to the south, included winds from 040 degrees true at 15, gusting to 24 knots, overcast skies at 7,500 feet, 10 miles visibility, temperature 45 degrees F, dew point 27 degrees F, and an altimeter setting of 30.18 inches Hg.

WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION

The impact sequence commenced in trees just west of a ridgeline in the vicinity of 39 degrees, 25.44 minutes north latitude, 080 degrees 26.78 minutes west longitude at an elevation of about 1,370 feet. Severed hardwoods, some up to 18 inches in diameter, were sheared in an approximately 15-degree descending path after the first tree strikes. The downward path, heading about 130 degrees magnetic, ended in a large ground scar on the ridgeline. Beyond the ground scar, and descending beyond the ridgeline, were the scattered remnants of the highly fractured airplane, with the largest piece, part of the cabin roof attached to the right wing, wrapped around a tree about 100 feet below the ridgeline. The most distant object, the engine, came to rest about 150 yards from the initial impact point, and 150 feet below the ridgeline.

The majority of the airplane was accounted for at the accident the site; however, due to an incoming winter storm, documentation was suspended. Prior to departure, all three propeller blades were located separate from the propeller hub, with one exhibiting torsional bending, leading edge damage and a separated tip, one exhibiting torsional bending and leading edge damage near the tip, and the last exhibiting a lesser degree of bending. The separated panel containing the three engine controls was also located; the mixture was in, and the propeller rpm and throttle were mostly pulled out; however, due to the extent of damage to the airplane, the actual control positions at impact could not be determined.

The wreckage was recovered after sufficient snow melt and was taken to a storage facility for further documentation. There, evidence of all flight controls surfaces was confirmed. Flight control continuity could not be completely determined due to the fractured nature of the wreckage. The rudder control cables were continuous from the cockpit to the aft rudder bellcrank that was separated. The aileron flight control cables were continuous from the cockpit to each respective wing aileron outboard bellcrank, but the left and right aileron pull cables were separated from their respective aileron control bellcrank, separated in the cockpit area, and the aileron balance cable was separated at the right aileron outboard bellcrank and at the rear spar carry-through. The cable separations exhibited splayed ends and individual filaments consistent with tensile overload. Elevator flight control cable continuity could not be determined.

The engine was severely impact damaged, and the exhaust system exhibited bending and folding, consistent with heat having been applied at impact. Crankshaft continuity was confirmed, and top spark plugs were gray in color. Neither magneto was recovered.

The fuel pump was rotated freely by hand. The fuel manifold valve diaphragm was intact. The retaining nut and plunger were tight and secure. The fuel screen exhibited a minor amount of dirt and the fuel manifold valve cavity had impacted dirt. Three of the fuel nozzles were fractured or bent, and could not be removed. The other three were removed and noted to be free of debris.

The throttle body/metering unit exhibited impact damage. The throttle and mixture control arms were bent but moved freely by hand from stop to stop. The throttle plate was moved freely by hand, and the fuel screen was free of debris.

The oil pump was disassembled with no preexisting anomalies were noted, and the internal element oil filter was absent of metal.

MEDICAL AND PATHOLOGICAL INFORMATION

An autopsy was performed on the pilot at West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia, where the cause of death and manner of death were noted as "Undetermined." The autopsy was limited by the degree of damage to the body; specifically, no heart or brain was available for examination.

Toxicological testing was hampered by a lack of blood or other body fluids available for testing. Initial testing by the medical examiner revealed the presence of mirtazapine and ethanol in muscle at 0.07%.

Subsequent toxicological testing was performed at the FAA's Civil Aerospace Medical Institute, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, where amlodipine, mirtazapine, and valsartan were found, but no ethanol in tissue specimens.

A Medical Factual Report was produced by the NTSB Chief Medical Officer. The basis for the report included the pilot's medical certification file, the accident's FAA medical case review, the pilot's toxicology results, autopsy report, personal medical records, and witness statements and observations from the investigator in charge. The complete report can be found in the public docket for this accident investigation.

Personal medical records were subpoenaed from the pilot's physician, who was also the pilot's FAA-designated Aviation Medical Examiner (AME), and who produced only five pages of records through October 12, 2009. In summary, the pilot had a history of hypertension, depression, and anxiety, and had suffered a stroke in 2008. The physician prescribed multiple medications for those conditions during visits for personal medical care in 2008 and 2009, including two medications the FAA considered disqualifying for use by pilots. Neither the pilot nor the AME reported these conditions or their treatment to the FAA when the pilot obtained aviation medical certificates from the same physician/AME in 2010 and 2012.

As noted in the Medical Factual Report, "In a study that followed patients after a stroke that left them with no or minimal disability, the risk of recurrent major stroke was 14% and the risk of death from any cause was 32% by 10 years later. Recurrent minor stroke, diabetes, heart attack, and hypertension significantly increased the risk of recurrent major stroke. In a more recent study, the combined risk of recurrent stroke or death from any cause was 10% at one year, 26% at five years, and 45% at 10 years following a stroke. These rates are about double the risk of the stroke-free population. Risk of both stroke and death was increased by having had a heart attack, diabetes, or hypertension.

Current recommendations for treatment following transient ischemic attacks and ischemic strokes are designed to decrease the likelihood of a recurrent event. Guidelines include ongoing treatment with antiplatelet medications such as aspirin or clopidogrel, evaluation and aggressive treatment of cholesterol, and careful management of hypertension and diabetes."

There were no records provided or any indication from the family as to who prescribed the pilot's current medications, or who might have been treating him if not the personal physician /AME.

Witnesses also reported that the pilot was slurring his speech within the 2 weeks preceding accident. Witnesses further indicated his possibly having suffered mini-stokes at that time, but family members denied any knowledge of them. They also noted that the pilot had recently retired and was looking forward to moving south in the near future.

NTSB Probable Cause

A stroke or cardiovascular event, which resulted in the pilot’s acute impairment or incapacitation and his subsequent flight into terrain.